"Ah, my dear," she said, closing her eyes. "All's well that ends well — but how much grief there was before it ended well!"
(A. Chekhov, "The Story of an Unknown Man")
As so often happens in everyday life, we run into all sorts of unpleasant and not always clear situations almost daily, and we don't always know how to behave or what to do in each particular case. We all live amid the rush of daily life and simply cannot physically keep everything under control. Some cases turn out oddly, even comically — the kind of thing you'd expect from a sitcom or a hidden-camera show.
In short, given all this — and we've written about it before — road users often find themselves thinking, "should I just leave the scene?", or "nothing much happened," or "no one saw it, so why not just disappear," and so on. Some get away with it, while others end up "sweating it out," since there's often a "bored, upstanding retiree" at a nearby window who saw everything and reported it right away…
For such cases, the law provides a specific penalty for leaving the scene of an accident — §142 of the German Criminal Code (Strafgesetzbuch).
This article covers a rather peculiar situation our client found himself in: believing the damage caused by his vehicle was minor, and simply not wanting to deal with the police, he left the scene of the accident.
But first, from the beginning…
A young Canadian citizen named Donald (name changed) came to our law firm. He lives permanently with his German wife in Germany, in a small, cozy town where everyone knows everyone else — not just by sight, but by name.
Donald found himself in an unfortunate situation: pulling up to his house, he parked poorly and forgot to set the handbrake. The car rolled down the slope, clipping his neighbor's parked car and damaging a fence and gate.
Flustered and unsure what to do, the young man looked around, satisfied himself that no one had noticed the mishap, and immediately — almost on autopilot — decided to simply re-park his car somewhere else.
Once home, shaken and stammering, he told his wife what had happened. Fortunately, Donald's wife was a woman of principle and decided the matter had to be set right immediately — a "Solomonic" decision was made to go to the neighbor and settle things amicably, i.e., with money — but she wasn't home, and no one answered the door.
That same evening, they went back to see the affected neighbor once she had returned home. The couple told the "victim" about the accident and agreed on compensation for the damage, which was paid in full a week later — after which she loudly announced to the couple that she had no further complaints against Donald.
In fairness to Donald and his wife, it's worth noting that on the day of the incident, and after speaking with the affected neighbor, the couple informed the police of what had happened, stating clearly that there had been no intent on Donald's part — in legal terms, his conduct had been unintentional.
A month later — after the young family's budget had shrunk by the amount paid to the neighbor — our "hero" Donald received a letter from the police summoning him for questioning. The summons (Vorladung) named Donald as a suspect in a crime under §142 of the German Criminal Code, which penalizes unlawfully leaving the scene of a traffic accident. Our client was stunned and baffled to find himself accused not only of causing the accident, but of having fled the scene. The recently forgotten episode with the neighbor had, by some twist of fate, come back to ruin Donald's mood — and his peace of mind.
Under §142(1) of the German Criminal Code, a party to a traffic accident in Germany who leaves the scene before making it possible to establish their identity, their vehicle, and the extent of their involvement in the accident can be held criminally liable. Leaving the scene of an accident is punishable by up to 3 years' imprisonment or a fine.
Donald never expected this turn of events and wasn't prepared to defend his rights on his own, so he turned to a lawyer for help. The young man was in a state of shock, one hundred percent certain that this was all a misunderstanding, since he had already compensated the neighbor for the damage. In a shaky voice typical of an anxious Canadian, he tried to explain to the lawyer that this was all "the doing of bad people," some kind of "misunderstanding," that he was "clean" before the law since he had reimbursed the neighbor for everything a month earlier, and so on.
Emotions, however, are not legal concepts, and lawyers work with different criteria altogether…
As is customary in such cases, the attorney requested the case file from the police. The file revealed additional facts: an unwitting witness to the accident turned out to be, as so often happens, another elderly woman living nearby, who heard the noise and went to her window, where she saw the following scene. A young man was standing next to his car; nearby stood the neighbor's damaged car and the wrecked fence. He then got behind the wheel of his own car and drove off. The vigilant "retiree" immediately wrote down his license plate number and just as quickly called the police to report the incident.
Police did not respond to the scene immediately — they respond urgently only when there are injured parties. By the time police arrived, the affected neighbor had already returned home and given her statement. Only after the police arrived did Donald and his wife report the incident themselves.
Having studied the case file, the attorney advised the client of the legal risks and the chances of successfully having the criminal case against Donald closed — a course of action Donald agreed to.
Building a persuasive argument always requires undeniable facts, established from every angle. First, our client was accused of leaving the scene of an accident; under German law he was required, after the accident, to wait for the police and the affected neighbor to arrive, or to leave a note with his personal contact details. It was essential for the attorney to prove that our client had not, in fact, concealed his identity by leaving the scene. In his submission, he petitioned to have the case closed for lack of a criminal offense under §170(2) of the German Code of Criminal Procedure. The law does not clearly define the "scene of the accident" or what "fleeing the scene" means, but case law provides guidance on these points. The affected neighbor's house is located no more than 10 meters from our client's house, so moving his car that short distance cannot be treated as leaving the scene — he simply re-parked the car rather than fleeing.
Second, he had tried to inform the affected neighbor of what had happened, but, for reasons beyond his control, she was not home at the time. The case file also confirmed that the woman was away until 2:30 PM, and the client had a witness — his wife. Additionally, §142 StGB contains a provision stating that if the person responsible for an accident voluntarily reports it to the police within 24 hours, criminal liability for leaving the scene may be waived.
Third, the attorney pointed out that the law does not clearly define the threshold for property damage, but case law indicates that damage from an accident on a public road is considered minor up to €750, and damage from an accident on a shoulder, in a yard, or in a parking lot is considered minor up to €1,200.
Based on the case file obtained and reviewed by the attorney, the damage caused by the accident amounted to roughly €1,000, which qualifies as minor damage — meaning the case could be closed. The attorney's argument in the client's defense proved unassailable, leading the public prosecutor's office to agree to close the criminal case against our client "for lack of a criminal offense" — exactly the outcome Donald's attorney had petitioned for.
It's worth noting that successfully closing a case without negative consequences for the client is difficult to achieve without the help of an experienced attorney — one who has the right to review the investigation file at the prosecutor's office (photos, interrogation records, etc.) and who has the necessary knowledge and experience with similar cases. In criminal law especially, evidence plays a crucial role, but if that evidence is misinterpreted or creates a false impression of what happened, there is always a risk of harming rather than helping the client. False or insufficiently proven accusations are fairly common. When a case involves some minor offense, many people simply agree, plead guilty, and pay, say, a fine as a punishment they may not have deserved at all — all because they're unwilling to argue about a subject they don't understand. Proving something in court isn't something everyone can do without experience and the relevant knowledge. Sometimes a single consultation is enough to understand what the real problem is, and how to resolve it faster and more advantageously for you.
This story illustrates just how important timely legal assistance is in resolving difficult situations. An experienced attorney can not only defend your position but also gather the necessary evidence and build a solid argument to protect your interests. For our part, we hope you never find yourself in such an unpleasant situation — but if you do, don't act rashly: weigh everything carefully and consult a qualified attorney.
All rights reserved. Copying or republishing this article requires a link to the original source.
