In 2013, amendments were made to the Act on Displaced Persons (BVFG) — the law under which late-resettler status can be obtained. The Act has been in force since 1993. To qualify for this status, an applicant must be ethnically German, resident in one of the republics of the former USSR (excluding the Baltic states), and must not fall under a number of exclusions, primarily those concerning senior officials of the "Soviet regime," criminals, and terrorists. The applicant must also have been born before 1 January 1993 and have resided in the USSR from birth, or from 8 May 1945 (or, in the case of forced "displacement," from 31 March 1952). If the applicant was born in the USSR after 8 May 1945 (or 31 March 1952), the residency requirement from those dates must instead be met by the ancestors from whom their "German origin" descends. Applicants must also have German proficiency sufficient to sustain a simple conversation, and must identify and present themselves to third parties as German. A number of additional restrictions applied before 2013: a refusal of late-resettler status could not be reapplied for; applicants had to speak one of the German dialects historically found among ethnic German communities in the USSR; and children and grandchildren of individuals who had suffered ethnicity-based repression could not file their own applications for the status. Cases were typically decided within three years; today, the general practice is a decision within one to two years, provided the required documents are submitted on time and the German-language requirement is met. The law has become more lenient on many points, but plenty of pitfalls left over from the earlier rules still lie beneath its surface — and our client Vitaly, from Kazakhstan, had every chance of running aground on exactly such a reef, had he not turned for help to our firm's experienced lawyers, who have specialized in late-resettler cases for many years.
You Can't Step in the Same River Twice
Conditions for Obtaining the Status
Late-resettler status requires proof of German ethnicity, a lasting affiliation with German culture, and German proficiency at a family-transmitted level (§ 6 BVFG).
Vitaly's parents had applied for late-resettler status back in the 1990s, but were refused because his father was unable to pass the language test. The family gave up hope of returning to their ancestral homeland and had to go on building their plans around the place of their earlier exile. His father worked and ran the household; all the children obtained higher education and kept themselves busy in their own right. But when the law on late resettlers changed four years ago, Vitaly, without much deliberation, filed his own application for the status. His father had by then made his peace with his fate and had no wish to go to Germany — but under the new rules, that was no longer necessary. Vitaly and his family could pursue the status independently.
They filled out and submitted the application with all the required documents, and from that point life lost its calm rhythm. Every future plan now revolved around moving to Germany; nothing more seemed worth planning in Kazakhstan, yet the nagging doubt remained — what if it's refused? The premonition proved right. As the saying goes, fears have a way of coming true. The situation felt almost uncanny, but the ones who could resolve it weren't sorcerers — they were lawyers based in Germany. The refusal gave no reasoning for why late-resettler status had been denied, and filing an appeal from another country was a procedural non-starter. Vitaly turned to our law firm for help.
Turning Back the Clock
It often happens that a client, before ever seeking a lawyer's help, has already taken a series of missteps. And the angle of reflection, as we all remember from the optics unit of school physics, equals the angle of incidence — with rare fortunate exceptions, that same principle holds in the legal sphere too: the wrong moves lead away from the desired outcome. A lawyer, as a result, often ends up playing the role of emergency responder, called in once "the patient has already prescribed their own course of treatment, overdosing on the wrong pills for the wrong illness." This was exactly such a case. In law, as in medicine, time is an enormous factor in how matters unfold. Different case strategies exist, but in every scenario, forming a clear picture and gathering the documents needed to build a strategy requires some buffer of time. The statutory deadline for filing an appeal had to be met, and the time that review would take would buy our lawyers the breathing room needed to gather documents and plan the next steps.
Our lawyer requested the official records of Vitaly's case. These would clarify the exact reason for the refusal of late-resettler status. According to the Bundesverwaltungsamt (BVA) officials, Vitaly's German ancestry had not been proven — the central requirement for the status, proof of affiliation with the German people, was, in the official's view, missing. We knew that roughly twenty years earlier, Vitaly's family had already applied for late-resettler status in Germany and had been refused at that time, so we decided to request the records of that earlier case as well. Comparing the documents from both cases revealed the very same legal pitfall that threatened to wreck Vitaly's and his family's plans for a life in Germany, shattering his childhood dream of living in his ancestors' homeland. Because Vitaly's father had failed the language test decades earlier, he had been denied recognition of German ethnicity — and Vitaly automatically lost the same status, since he was now legally descended from someone not recognized as German. Such are the quirks of the law. The only way out of this situation, as we saw it, was to have Vitaly's father's case reopened. But he had, by his own account, long given up his dream of the ancestral homeland and had no intention of leaving his current life behind — nor did his health allow for such a dramatic change.
Vitaly nonetheless managed to persuade his father to reconsider and pursue late-resettler status a second time. But this raised an even more serious problem: an elderly man in his condition would never be able to pass a language test. The only way forward was to establish a medical condition that would exempt him from the language exam. To our client's credit, every medical examination was completed in record time — the remaining task was simply to obtain a certificate in the right form. Doctors in Russia, Kazakhstan, and Ukraine typically issue documents containing a full case history without drawing any conclusions about what a patient can or cannot do as a result — leaving that interpretation to the recipient. The German legal system, by contrast, is built around a different logic: it is the doctor who must draw that conclusion. Our lawyer sent Vitaly a template for the kind of medical opinion that would satisfy German officials, and — to everyone's relief — the doctor in Kazakhstan understood exactly what was needed and agreed to issue the document in a form matching German standards.
This Is Our Final, Decisive Battle
By this point, our appeal had been refused, and our lawyers had prepared a court filing to challenge the resettler authority's decision. The documents on Vitaly's father arrived with only a narrow gap in timing, allowing us to file with the court to have him granted late-resettler status without sitting the language test — his condition prevented him from absorbing new information, and stress posed a serious threat to his continued well-being. A new problem now emerged, however: as our practice had shown, case-processing timelines were badly out of sync. Vitaly's own case could be expected to take at most three months, while his father's case could take the court up to three years to decide. We therefore asked the court to freeze Vitaly's proceedings until a decision was reached on his father's case.
Facing what looked like an imminent loss, the BVA approached us with a request to withdraw Vitaly's application, guaranteeing that if his father's case were decided favorably, Vitaly would automatically receive late-resettler status as well. For the resettler authority, this was the optimal way out — beyond losing the case, it also faced having to cover Vitaly's court and legal costs. Our client accepted the terms, and in early November of that year, the court ruled in favor of granting late-resettler status to Vitaly's father. Whether this elderly gentleman will ever actually make the journey to his ancestral homeland remains an open question — but thanks to our lawyers' persistence and professionalism, the road to a new future is now open to Vitaly and his family. Two weeks after the favorable decision on his father's case, Vitaly received the long-awaited admission permit (Aufnahmebescheid) from the Federal Administrative Office for himself and his family members (Einbeziehungsbescheid).
All rights reserved. Copying or republishing this article requires a link to the original source.
